Categories
Uncategorized

Time to put nostalgia in the past

I don’t believe it’s contentious to say that we live in a culture that loves to look back. In fashion, the ’80s revival – the second (at least) in living memory – has been quickly followed by a ’90s revival (ditto). In cinema we have films based on 1960s superhero comics and popular childhood games franchises like Battleships or Rampage. In music bands like Tame Impala are unselfconsciously modelled on ’70s rock while young artists such as Jamie XX make music that’s soaked in nostalgia for a time they surely can’t remember.

Recently Cennydd Bowles, after watching the band Godspeed! You Black Emperor, was driven to write this:

I’m tired of bygone-era fetishisation. What would a futurist Godspeed sound like? A band of similar scope but a palette more RGB than sepia? I’d be more interested by a Godspeed whose visuals would be drones/VR/scarcity rather than film strips/manuscripts/burned buildings. Is anyone making music that asks legitimate questions about the future, rather than the past or present?

The filmmaker Adam Curtis has a theory that our culture is static, that there is no progression in the popular arts and media, which he expounds very neatly in an interview with New Statesman:

All culture always goes back and feeds off the past, it can’t help it, but there are two ways of doing it. Either you can go back and get inspiration from the past and create something genuinely new, which is the whole history of all sorts of things – not just art and music. What bothers me at the moment is that you get a very different sense out of pop culture, which is that it is literally like a form of archaeology.

It should be noted that I’m not against referencing history – I strongly believe that we can use history to provide more context about modern society. What I’m explicitly deploring is nostalgia – because, as David Denby says in Has Hollywood Murdered the Movies?:

Nostalgia is history altered through sentiment.

This idea of pop culture’s slavish devotion to the past heavily informs Laura Hudson’s review of Ernest Cline’s Armada, his ’80s-referencing follow-up to his ’80s-referencing best-selling debut:

Do we want to tell stories that make sense of the things we used to love, that help us remember the reasons we were so drawn to them, and create new works that inspire that level of devotion? Or do we simply want to hear the litany of our childhood repeated back to us like an endless lullaby for the rest of our lives?

This is the important part: “create new works”. What Cennydd and Adam and Laura all make clear is that to make an interesting future we need to actually think about the future. To further quote from the David Denby piece:

What’s necessary for survival is not nostalgia, but defiance.

Categories
Uncategorized

Some nuggets from the Digital News Report 2015

The Digital News Report 2015 (Oxford University / Reuters Institute) makes for interesting reading even if you don’t work online news and journalism. It’s like a snapshot of a cultural transition. Mobile is pinpointed as the major change driver, but not in the news apps you might expect, rather through social sharing and video.

There are plenty of fascinating insights in there, but one that really stood out to me is how drastically different the UK news market is from the rest of the world: because of the BBC.

In the UK, over half of smartphone news users (51%) regularly use the BBC News app, the only country where we see this level of reach.

This goes some way to explaining why large sections of the established old media want to see the BBC broken up – and why it’s important to defend it:

Many of the countries with the highest levels of trust also have well-funded public service broadcasters.

Away from old media, this is a BIG change:

Only in Japan is Facebook NOT the largest network for news.

I’d never really considered before how the passive exposure to news is greater on Facebook:

In Facebook the pursuit of news is secondary, with the main aim being communicating with friends. Twitter, on the other hand, is seen much more as an active destination for news by an audience that is deeply interested in latest developments.

The filter bubble also seems not to be an issue, with users (self-)reporting that this passive exposure means they see a broader range of news sources than they might otherwise choose:

Three-quarters of social media users (76%) and search users (73%) said they sometimes or frequently accessed different sources – leading them to brands they would not otherwise use.

I wonder how that compares between Facebook and Twitter. My instinctive presumption is that exposure is more narrow on Twitter as you’re more selective about following people whose views broadly follow your own, whereas on Facebook your choices are more dictated by family and friends – I know I would rarely be exposed to far-right material if it weren’t for my racist cousin…

There seems to be somewhat of a backlash against web advertising recently, perhaps brought on by the fact that so much of it is annoying, distracting and intrusive.

It is not surprising that many publishers are abandoning the old models in favour of new ‘native’ advertising or sponsored content.

Which is great… but for this:

A third or more say they have felt disappointed or deceived after reading an article they later found had been sponsored. Over a quarter feel less positively about the news brand as a result of sponsored content or native advertising.

If people don’t like sponsored content, and aren’t willing to sign up for paywalls, and don’t even like adverts at all in many cases, perhaps there’s scope for the growth of micropayments in the future.