Categories
Uncategorized

How popular are Roblox branded experiences?

This year lots of brands launched experiences on Roblox; some to catch the ‘metaverse’ hype, some for experimentation, and some with a genuine desire to engage a young audience in playful social spaces.

Roblox publicly records the number or visits to each experience, which can give you some idea of popularity, although it doesn’t list unique visits. However, some experiences reward every user with a badge for visiting for the first time, so we can use that, where available, to record unique visits.

Gucci Town’s Welcome badge shows how many users entered for the first time

I looked at a number of branded experiences to find those with a first-time user award, and you can see their relative popularity in the chart below. It’s not a fair like-for-like as some have been online for longer than others, but I still think it’s worthwhile to take a look. The chart shows total visit numbers, in millions, with unique visits recorded in a darker shade.

Data gathered on 15/12/2022

In absolute numbers, NARS Color Quest is the most popular experience to date, with almost 42 million visits (it also has the highest user approval rating, 86%, of all the experiences in the chart). But Gucci Town and Nikeland have the joint-highest number of unique visitors: 11.6 million apiece. Considering Roblox states 58.8 million daily active users, that’s good going.

Working from the total visits and unique visitors we can get a record of how many times each user returned, on average. This is shown in the chart below (note that I’ve excluded some of the least-visited experiences as their results seemed skewed):

Data gathered on 15/12/2022

NARS Color Quest might not have had the highest number of unique visitors, but it has by far the highest number of total visits, as each of its users returned over three times, on average. Gucci Town and Nikeland have had an equal number of unique visitors, but Gucci ranks much higher in return visits, with 2.26 to Nikeland’s 1.45. Note also here that Spotify Island and iHeartLand Music Tycoon do well in returning visitors. Visitors to Walmart Land have only came back for an average of 0.5 visits (and it has a user approval rating of just 58%).

There are a lot of conclusions that can be inferred from this small study, but I need to explore them in more detail and with more scientific rigour when I have more time. In the meantime, if you’re wondering how well some of these branded experiences do, perhaps this will help.

And if you come across a branded experience which has a welcome / first-time badge but which I haven’t included here, be sure to let me know.


NB I updated the title of this post after publishing; it was originally “How Successful are Roblox Branded Experiences?”, but we can’t really measure success without knowing goals, so “popular” fits better.

Categories
Uncategorized

Data Privacy, Control, Transparency, and Regulation

I’ve written about privacy and personal data a few times before, and my conclusion generally remains the same: our data has value, and we should be able to benefit from the use of it, but we must be provided with control and transparency, backed up by strong regulation.

Pertinent to this, I was interested to read The Future Is Data Integrity, Not Confidentiality. This is an extract from a talk by Toomas Hendrik Ilves, President of Estonia, where they’re creating a digital society. In this talk he says:

“We have a law that says you own your own data. And you can see who has tried to access your data.”

And in What Happens Next Will Amaze You, the latest in a long line of excellent talks/essays by Maciej Cegłowski, he lays out six fixes for the busted internet power model (where users are somewhere near the bottom). These fixes include:

You should have the right to download data that you have provided, or that has been collected by observing your behavior, in a usable electronic format.

You should have the right to completely remove [your] account and all associated personal information from any online service, whenever [you] want.

Companies should only be allowed to store behavioral data for 90 days. Companies should be prohibited from selling or otherwise sharing behavioral data.

And, perhaps most important of all, there is a requirement for:

A legal mechanism to let companies to make enforceable promises about their behavior.

This is exactly what I mean. This is what I think the future should look like: we benefit from our personal and aggregated public data, with control and transparency, backed up by strong regulation. Who do we talk to, to make this happen?

Categories
Uncategorized

Data use and privacy in Web services

Tim Cook recently made a speech attacking Silicon Valley companies (e.g. Google and Facebook) for making money by selling their users’ privacy. The problem with what he said is that, first of all, it’s fundamentally incorrect. As Ben Thompson points out (subscription required):

It’s simply not true to say that Google or Facebook are selling off your data. Google and Facebook do know a lot about individuals, but advertisers don’t know anything — that’s why Google and Facebook can charge a premium! [They] are highly motivated to protect user data – their competitive advantage in advertising is that they have data on customers that no one else has.

Cennydd Bowles also argues the same point:

The “you are the product” thing is pure sloganeering. It sounds convincing on first principles but doesn’t hold up to analysis. It’s essentially saying all two-sided platforms are immoral, which is daft.

The @StartupLJackson Twitter account puts this more plainly:

People who argue free-to-customer data companies (FB/Goog/etc) are selling data & hurting consumers are the anti-vaxxers of our industry.

I’ve always maintained that this is about a value exchange – you can use my data, as long as I get control and transparency over who sees it, and a useful service in return. But beyond that, another problem with making premium services where you pay for privacy is that you make a two-tier system. Cennydd again:

The supposition that only a consumer-funded model is ethically sound is itself political and exclusionary (of the poor, children, etc).

And Kate Crawford:

Two-tier social media: the rich pay to opt out of Facebook ads, the poor get targeted endlessly. Privacy becomes a luxury good.

Aside: Of course this suits Apple, as if wealthier clients can afford to opt out of advertising, then advertising itself becomes less valuable – as do, in turn, Google and Facebook.

The fact that people are willing to enter into a data exchange which benefits them when they get good services in return highlights the second problem with Tim Cook’s attack: Apple are currently failing to provide good services. As Thomas Ricker says in his snappily-titled Tim Cook brings a knife to a cloud fight:

Fact is, Apple is behind on web services. Arguably, Google Maps is better than Apple Maps, Gmail is better than Apple Mail, Google Drive is better than iCloud, Google Docs is better than iWork, and Google Photos can “surprise and delight” better than Apple Photos.

And even staunch Apple defender Jon Gruber agreed:

Apple needs to provide best-of-breed services and privacy, not second-best-but-more-private services. Many people will and do choose convenience and reliability over privacy. Apple’s superior position on privacy needs to be the icing on the cake, not their primary selling point.

As this piece by Jay Yarow for Business Insider points out, in the age of machine learning, more data makes better services. Facebook and Google are ahead in services because they make products that understand their users better than Apple do.