Categories
Uncategorized

Is Firefly 2 a first-class image generation model?

Adobe just released the second version of Firefly, its image generation model. While models such as Stable Diffusion and Midjourney are the market leaders in terms of result quality, the uncertainty (warranted or otherwise) about the datasets they’ve used in their training means that it’s important to have strong rivals that are trained on licensed data.

I had high hopes for Firefly when it was released, but unfortunately it fell short in many areas. So is Firefly 2 any better? In short, yes. But is it good enough to be a viable contender? Well, let’s take a look.

Below are three tests I’ve been tracking. For each I’m going to show the prompt I used, followed by the results in (1) Firefly 2, (2) Firefly 1, and (3) Midjourney.

close-up portrait photograph, a young Korean woman with pink hair, holding a tan Shiba Inu puppy, smiling joyfully, studio lighting

With a simple, single-subject image, all three models give a decent result. Firefly 1 handled this well already, and Firefly 2 is a little improved. This is the prompt that got the worst result from Midjourney; the image is fine, but it doesn’t seem to know what a Shiba Inu is.

candid photograph, a group of young boys and girls standing in a London street, mixed ethnicities, natural light

Firefly 1 struggled badly with shots featuring multiple subjects; some of the poses were awkward, the faces have strange details, and the scale is very weird. Firefly 2 shows a huge improvement here. But Midjourney really nails this shot; it looks great.

a Highland cow on a Harley Davidson motorcycle, wide mountain road, golden hour, freedom, speed

This is an unusual combination of subjects; Highland cows riding motorcycles isn’t very common in photography. Firefly 1 didn’t give a great result; it’s forced and unnatural, the ‘golden hour’ lighting isn’t very strong, and it doesn’t give any feeling of freedom and speed. Firefly 2 improves the composition, and the lighting is much better, but it’s still not a great, coherent image. Again Midjourney gets this spot-on; creative combination, strong lighting, and emotive.

The improvement of Firefly 2 over Firefly 1 is clear, and it’s now competitive with Midjourney in some cases; but it’s still a lot less creative. However this is a far from comprehensive test, and I’m sure as I use Firefly 2 more I’ll discover its strengths.